Paul's Pumpkin Bars
Fiftieth anniversary issue*
Legend has it a man named Paul mailed a recipe to a magazine in 1976. It has been at bake sales ever since.
*Give or take. Nobody kept the receipt.
24 bars. Go on, take one.
Inside
- The recipe, first, with no life story
- How to cut a pan 6 ways
- An accountant's cost per bar
- Fifty years of frosting inflation
- The hunt for Paul
The recipe
One bowl of wet, one bowl of dry, one ungreased pan.
This is the 1976 formula, the way the magazine printed it.1 Turn the dials and every number on the page follows: the ingredients, the method, the cut and the ledger.
From the kitchen of
Paul
Bars
Frosting
Method
The cut
How many bars is a pan of bars?
The magazine said 24. The knife is in your hand.
The ledger
Legend has it Paul was an accountant.3
So here are the books. Prices are rough U.S. grocery guesses. Type over them with what's on your receipt and the cost per bar reconciles itself.
| Item | You buy | Price | Used | Cost |
|---|
Depreciation of pan: not material. Labor: donated. Bars eaten before frosting: off the books.
The drift
A recipe is a rumor that gets retyped.
Fifty years of index cards, church cookbooks and recipe sites have each changed Paul's bars a little. Here is the version history, diffed against the original.1
The five numbers nobody has dared touch
- 4 eggs
- 1⅔ cups sugar
- 1 cup oil
- 1 can pumpkin
- 2 cups flour
Frosting inflation, 1976 → now
Same pan of bars. The cake held still. The frosting did not.5
The man, the myth
Who was Paul?
Everybody has made his pumpkin bars. Nobody has met him. Here is what is on paper: Better Homes & Gardens printed a reader's recipe, left the name Paul on it, and when its food editor ran it again years later, under a headline promising that leftovers were unlikely, she said only that it came from a reader and that the staff had never found a pumpkin bar they liked as well.1 That's it. That's the file.
The rest is legend. Legend has it the year was 1976.2 The rumor mill says his full name was Paul Rainbow, which is almost too good, and one baker working from a page her mother saved thanks him by exactly that name.3 Some say he was an accountant, written up in a column about men who cook. Some say he retired to Palm Springs, which is where a legend would go.
Others tell it differently. One family swears the bars are named for their own Paul, a dad who simply loved them. Another passed the recipe down for a generation and admits they have no idea where it came from. Plenty of people bake them every fall and have never heard the name at all.
We choose the accountant. It's the only story that explains the recipe. Round numbers. Nothing wasted. One can, not three-quarters of one. It balances.
If you knew Paul, or you are Paul, this site would very much like to hear from you.
Evidence